Telegram CEO warns of the end of the free internet

Last update: October 17, 2025
  • Telegram CEO Pavel Durov warns of the accelerating decline in internet privacy and freedom.
  • It highlights measures in the EU, the UK, and Australia: message scanning, digital identification, and age verification.
  • Opposition grows: Germany's key stance, criticism from experts and leaders like Vitalik and Signal.

This is what Pavel Durov, CEO of Telegram, said about the future of the internet.

The debate about internet freedom has returned to the forefront after Pavel Durov, founder and CEO of Telegram, posted a particularly strong message on his 41st birthday. On his public profiles and his own channel, the entrepreneur warns that the open internet may be entering its final stages , dragged down by new regulations and controls that, in his view, erode fundamental rights.

Durov's warning is not merely a generic complaint. The executive focuses on current government decisions that, under the guise of security and regulation, could transform the internet into a surveillance mechanism. He specifically targets digital identification in the UK, age verification systems implemented in Australia, and the European proposal for the mass scanning of private messages. All of this, he warns, paints a picture he describes as "dystopian," one from which his generation may be the last to escape.

Who is Pavel Durov and what exactly did he say?

Pavel Durov, a key figure in the digital ecosystem for his role in promoting Telegram, has for years argued that private communication must be inviolable. In his most recent message, he maintains that "what promised to be a free exchange of information" is mutating into "the ultimate tool of control." Without repeating his exact words, the central idea is unequivocal: privacy guarantees are being dismantled piece by piece through laws that open the door to inspections and identity linking.

Telegram founder opens artificial intelligence center in Kazakhstan
Related articles:
Telegram founder opens AI center in Kazakhstan

The statement didn't stay confined to his channel: it was also shared on X (formerly Twitter), and for hours, the Telegram app displayed a prominent banner linking to the text. This display, unusual for its visibility, underscores the gravity that Durov attributes to the current situation. For him, it's not a theoretical warning , but a call to action before it's too late.

The measures that set off the alarms, one by one

Pavel Durov's diagnosis is supported by concrete examples. According to his analysis, there are three fronts that encapsulate the regulatory drift: mandatory identity verification, age verification, and communication scanning . His criticism is that, combined, these erode anonymity, break encryption, and normalize pre-message screening.

  • Digital ID in the UK: a plan to associate activities and procedures with a state-verifiable identity.
  • Age verification in Australia: access control to social networks for minors under 16 years of age, with digital verification systems.
  • ChatControl in the EU: proposal to allow mass scanning of private messages and images under the guise of protecting minors.

For Durov, the problem isn't just technical. It's political and cultural. Normalizing these practices, he insists, leads to "the exceptional becoming routine." And when that happens, privacy ceases to be the rule and becomes a concession.

ChatControl in the EU: Political and Technical Challenge

Pavel Durov and his news about the Internet

Within the European Union, the proposal known as ChatControl has raised concerns among activists, cryptographers, and platforms. Its critics argue that requiring message inspection before encryption undermines the fundamental pillar of secure messaging. In recent days, opposition from Germany's largest political party has complicated its approval; with 97 seats, its influence is significant and has forced a reassessment of the timeline and forum for debate , shifting the battle to the European Council.

Signal's president, Meredith Whittaker, has summarized the consensus among security experts: there is no "backdoor" used only by the good guys. Any exception to the encryption creates vulnerabilities that can be exploited by malicious third parties. Her position is unequivocal: "Forcing content scanning invalidates end-to-end encryption." This, in effect, opens a systemic attack vector that affects millions of users.

The debate isn't new, but it has intensified. Vitalik Buterin, co-founder of Ethereum, has also questioned the direction of ChatControl and its impact on private communications. For technical experts of his caliber, the message is clear: the mathematics of encryption doesn't compromise . Either everyone is protected, or everyone is weakened.

Digital identity in the United Kingdom: promises and shadows

The UK government has launched a digital identification scheme that would validate the right to live and work, as well as facilitate public procedures such as obtaining licenses or accessing services. On paper, the aim is to streamline processes and curb the underground economy. But doubts quickly arise: who safeguards this data? What are the limits to its access? For civil groups and some citizens, therein lies the risk. Not in the identification itself, but in its subsequent use and the possibility of linking records that profile each person's life.

The rejection has coalesced into a massive petition with over 2,8 million signatures, far exceeding the usual thresholds for forcing debates in Parliament. This figure demonstrates that the issue transcends technicalities and falls squarely within the realm of constitutional rights and guarantees.

Australia and age verification: protecting minors without invading privacy

Australia has opted to restrict access to social media for those under 16 starting December 10th, and among the tools being considered is a digital age verification system. The underlying intention is understandable: to protect minors from harmful content . However, critics of the measure warn of a side effect: if sensitive databases are built to verify ages, incentives for their reuse will emerge, and with it, greater risks of leaks or abuse.

The balance, therefore, is delicate. The key question is how to validate age without forcing full identification and without storing excessive data. This "middle ground" is what digital rights organizations are demanding, fearing that the system's design will ultimately degrade anonymity in practice.

State pressure accusations: Germany, the United Kingdom, and France under Pavel Durov's spotlight

In his argument, Durov accuses some European countries of cracking down on critical voices. He cites Germany for prosecuting those who question the authorities, the United Kingdom for imprisoning people for social media posts, and France for criminally investigating tech leaders who defend privacy. These are statements we frame as his position; in any case, the message is clear: the space for dissent online is shrinking.

Beyond whether each case fits into specific criminal categories, the warning points to the context: when the legal environment is vague and the threshold of "punishable content" is broadened, a chilling effect occurs. People censor themselves. And that spiral, concludes Pavel Durov, impoverishes public debate and degrades democratic life.

Privacy, encryption, and the role of cryptocurrencies

Privacy is not a whim, the crypto ecosystem reminds us. Bitcoin was born with a pseudonymous design: addresses instead of names, direct peer-to-peer transfers, and the elimination of intermediaries like banks in the transaction flow. In that paradigm, identity protection is part of the design , not an afterthought; that's why many recommend password management solutions . Hence, many voices in the industry view with concern regulations that could indirectly force access to data or break encryption.

In Europe, even technologies designed to preserve confidentiality—such as Mimblewimble protocols or zero-knowledge testing—have come under stricter scrutiny. The reason is understandable: authorities are looking for tools to combat crime . The tension arises when proposed solutions extend surveillance to the entire population, not just suspects, thus undermining the principle of proportionality.

Telegram in the spotlight: piracy, controversy, and the incident in France

Telegram has frequently been criticized for the role some of its channels play in the illicit distribution of content, from sports broadcasts to TV series and movies. This use—which violates copyright—has generated friction with rights holders and regulators. Furthermore, in August 2024, Pavel Durov himself was arrested by French authorities as part of an investigation into illegal activities on the platform; later, the extent of Telegram's cooperation with law enforcement was clarified. The episode, in any case, forced internal changes and decisions that were unpopular with some members of its community.

Critics argue that the platform has been slow to address abusive behavior. Defenders, however, maintain that Telegram has consistently prioritized privacy without succumbing to general pressure. Between these two perspectives lies a fundamental question: is it possible to prosecute specific crimes without undermining the confidentiality that protects legitimate users?

Delete Telegram
Related articles:
Complete guide to deleting your Telegram account: steps, tips, and considerations

"They sold us a lie": the core of the argument

Pavel Durov argues that a narrative has taken hold suggesting that the great achievement of our time is to rid ourselves of tradition, privacy, sovereignty, the free market, and freedom of expression. In his view, this idea is a trap. Renouncing these principles doesn't make us more modern; it makes us more vulnerable and dependent . And when these pillars crumble, he warns, the decline becomes moral, intellectual, and economic.

The language is deliberately dramatic because it seeks a reaction. It's not common for the founder of a major platform to openly declare that he "has nothing to celebrate" on his birthday. This theatricality has a purpose: to stir his audience into understanding that the window of opportunity is closing.

The technical response: why back doors don't work

Security engineers and cryptographers have been explaining for decades that there are no secure exceptions to end-to-end encryption. A backdoor isn't a controlled privilege; it's a hole in the hull. At first glance, it might seem only useful for rescues at sea, but in the next minute, pirates will be using it too . That's the core argument of Signal and much of the cybersecurity technical community, and they remind us that privacy tools like apps for hiding files exist.

The paradox is that a "limited" weakening of encryption can end up causing more harm than it prevents. Documents, conversations, and proof of life for millions of people—journalists, activists, officials, ordinary citizens—depend on communications being inaccessible in transit. If even a small crack is opened, the risk multiplies systemically.

What the defenders of these laws say

Those who advocate for stricter regulations cite the protection of minors, the fight against abuse, and the need to equip authorities with modern tools. No one disputes these objectives. The clash arises when defining the means to achieve them : if the solution involves monitoring everyone to prosecute a few, the balance between security and freedom is disrupted.

Part of the discussion will be resolved on technical grounds—how to prove age without revealing identity, for example—and another part is undeniably political: what is the acceptable threshold for state intrusion? Here, the position of influential EU countries, such as Germany, could tip the scales, as has already been seen with the blocking of ChatControl and its referral to Council negotiations. This parliamentary dynamic will show the extent of the consensus on addressing encryption.

The echo in the crypto ecosystem and decentralization as an antidote

For Durov, decentralization is more than just a buzzword. It's the mechanism that limits the power of centralized control, whether by corporations or governments. This principle resonates with the philosophy of blockchain and with projects like TON, which aim to distribute trust across the network. From this perspective, protecting privacy is preserving the last frontier of personal freedom in the digital age.

The crypto sector, for its part, sees these discussions as a defining battle. It's not just a matter of assets, but of censorship-resistant communication and payment infrastructures. If encryption is compromised, the promise of secure peer-to-peer transactions and private messaging loses its force. That's why every attempt to "read" encrypted content generates a coordinated response from technologists and civil society organizations.

The United States in the Mirror: The Bias of Public Discussion

In his letter, Pavel Durov focused on Europe, the United Kingdom, and Australia, but similar debates are taking place in other parts of the world. In the United States, several states have proposed restrictions and controls for minors on app stores and social media. Some critics point out that this selective focus on specific countries also influences the perception of the problem. Nevertheless, the core argument remains: the global trend is toward more control , not less.

These comparisons serve as a reminder that no territory is immune to regulatory shortcuts. What is a pilot program in one country today may be standard practice in another tomorrow. That is why privacy advocates insist on establishing technical red lines: end-to-end encryption and the non-universal linking of identities should not be negotiable.

What is being decided now and why does it matter?

The European situation is particularly relevant: a decision on ChatControl would set a global precedent. If "preventive" message scanning becomes the norm, other jurisdictions could replicate it. If, on the other hand, encryption is recognized as a public good that cannot be breached, privacy will be strengthened . Therefore, the positions of major member states are being closely watched.

In the UK, the final scope of the digital identity scheme—what data is requested, how it is stored, and with whom it is shared—will determine whether the tool simplifies procedures or becomes a passport to surveillance. In Australia, the specific design of the age verification system will make the difference between protecting minors without intruding on adults or forcing the entire population to reveal more than they should in order to access the internet.

“If we remain asleep, a dark world will descend upon us,” Pavel Durov warned in his message. Beyond the drama, his central idea is that negligence has a cost: what is freedom by default today may become a fragile exception tomorrow.

The struggle won't end with a single vote or a viral thread. It's a process. And every decision—from a court, a parliament, a platform—has an impact, either positive or negative, in practice. That's why technical and civil voices insist on participating in public consultations, hearings, and debates. The goal isn't to deny the need to combat crime, but to achieve proportionate tools that don't condemn the majority to constant preventive surveillance.

What's at stake is not just how we communicate, but how we think and create when we feel like someone is watching us. For product designers, the message is clear: privacy by design, data minimization, and robust encryption, along with adequate security measures. For lawmakers, the challenge is to refine laws without undermining the technical foundations that make a secure internet for everyone possible. At this point, public pressure is often decisive.

How to disable the People Nearby feature in Telegram
Related articles:
Telegram: Turn off “People Nearby” and prevent tracking

The warnings from Pavel Durov, the German block on ChatControl, the reservations expressed by Signal and crypto leaders, identity verification plans in the UK and age verification in Australia, along with Telegram's controversial history and its defense of encryption, paint a picture that is not easy, but certainly clear: either we address the real risks with targeted, privacy-respecting solutions, or we will end up normalizing disproportionate controls that empty the original promise of the internet of its meaning. And in this situation, time is running out for those who want to maintain a truly free internet. Share this information so other users can learn about this issue.